Comments on: Ontologies, domain models, use cases, and the ecological approach (part 1) http://blogs.cetis.org.uk/johnr/2007/11/12/ontologies-domain-models-use-cases-and-the-ecological-approach/ Cetis Blogs Wed, 25 Jan 2012 12:47:46 +0000 hourly 1 http://wordpress.org/?v=4.1.22 By: Alan Paull http://blogs.cetis.org.uk/johnr/2007/11/12/ontologies-domain-models-use-cases-and-the-ecological-approach/#comment-12 Thu, 15 Nov 2007 13:45:44 +0000 http://blogs.cetis.org.uk/johnr/2007/11/12/ontologies-domain-models-use-cases-and-the-ecological-approach/#comment-12 John

We’re using a definition of domain model that is close to Tom Franklin’s recent work for JISC “A High Level Domain Architecture for HE”. From Tom’s report the definition is:
“A domain model can be thought of as a conceptual model of a system which describes the various entities involved in that system and their relationships. The domain model is created to
document the key concepts and the vocabulary of the system. The model displays the relationships among all major entities within the system and usually identifies their important methods and attributes (Wikipedia).”

I would slightly question the use of the term “system” in this definition, because there may not be a single clearly defined system involved, and perhaps even some stuff that isn’t actually system-like. We’re considering a ‘domain’ to be a specific area of interest or expertise, in our example, HE admissions. Domains can, I think, be at various levels of granularity; though it’s usually helpful to consider big chunks rather than fine detail.

Our work in ADoM is to develop a model for the HE admissions domain, and to develop a visualisation of this (a domain map), so that admissions practitioners can share their experiences, modify the model and suggest useful future (technological) developments in admissions. We’re gathering information from our primary project partners, University of Nottingham and Manchester Metropolitan University. We’re using Protege to hold the knowledge base and are currently working on a visualisation (a domain map) constructed by tweaking Protege’s HTML outputs and adding some of our own pages and diagrams.

Alan

]]>
By: JohnR http://blogs.cetis.org.uk/johnr/2007/11/12/ontologies-domain-models-use-cases-and-the-ecological-approach/#comment-11 Thu, 15 Nov 2007 10:30:36 +0000 http://blogs.cetis.org.uk/johnr/2007/11/12/ontologies-domain-models-use-cases-and-the-ecological-approach/#comment-11 Hi Alan,
I’ve put some of my working notes on the similarities and differences between a domain model and the ecological approach in another post. I’m still trying to understand domain models though so I may be off track. It’ll be interesting to hear some more about your project.
cheers,
John

]]>
By: Domain models and the ecological approach | John’s JISCCETIS blog http://blogs.cetis.org.uk/johnr/2007/11/12/ontologies-domain-models-use-cases-and-the-ecological-approach/#comment-10 Thu, 15 Nov 2007 10:26:29 +0000 http://blogs.cetis.org.uk/johnr/2007/11/12/ontologies-domain-models-use-cases-and-the-ecological-approach/#comment-10 […] a more focused brief discussion to follow up my last post about different approaches to modeling. It attempts to understand some of the similarities and […]

]]>
By: Alan Paull http://blogs.cetis.org.uk/johnr/2007/11/12/ontologies-domain-models-use-cases-and-the-ecological-approach/#comment-9 Wed, 14 Nov 2007 09:24:03 +0000 http://blogs.cetis.org.uk/johnr/2007/11/12/ontologies-domain-models-use-cases-and-the-ecological-approach/#comment-9 We’ve been working on domain model visualisation in the ADoM project (led by University of Nottingham), so we’ve been wrestling with some of the issues you have identified here. Our current front runner is to use a combination of “narratives” that hold scenarios together and give context, with “characteristic scales” that allow us to capture the critical environmental factors.

As an example, we have a narrative for assessing applicants in a professional subject, using holistic methods, for a heavily selecting course in a multi-site environment. We hope that the narrative and characteristics can capture the richness and some of the variety of the domain.

It occurs to me that our approach is quite close to the ecological approach you have outlined here. I’m particularly keen to record the messier aspects of the domain, which are most important to practitioners, even if they cannot be readily captured in business models.

]]>